Warning: this is a long one, kids.
Well, people of the Internet, it’s about time you learned: I’m a geek. What is a geek? It’s a nerd without the smarts. That’s me. I like movies and video games, but not just the cool ones that a guy my age is supposed to like, like God of War or Ratchet and Clank (both awesome); no, the first game I utterly conquered, the first game that I played until it was 100% complete, and which still holds a special place in my heart, was Pokémon Red.
I… I had to catch them all. ALL 150 OF THEM.
Much to my parent’s chagrin and confuzzlement, I was hooked. It was like crack, I imagine. I also imagine that from the outside looking in, it looks pretty stupid. Well, your face is stupid. Stupid face.
The point of this post, which is probably going to be more like a novel of some kind since we have five generations to go through, is to illustrate that the Pokémon that I grew up with were, by and large, better than the new ones. Kind of like the greatest generation: things were better back then, everything was fresh and new, and the possibilities were endless. Now, these stupid kids have their stupid shows and they don’t know what it was like to have to tilt your Game Boy just right in order to see the screen without glare, or how batteries needed changing every few hours because the brick went through them like a fat kid through a bag of Doritos.
GENERATION I
Look at them. They’re adorable. You’re seeing perfection there, folks: Bulbasaur, Charmander, and Squirtle. Imitated, emulated, never duplicated, these guys were the foundation upon which I wasted my 6th grade year. Introducing a generation to the idea that the Rock-Paper-Scissors trifecta could be applied to other areas. And then… then we found out they could evolve.
What?
Holy crap. Look at that. They got bigger, and even badder. Ivysaur grew some teeth there, Charmeleon got an angry look and a head spike, and Wartortle… has head wings and is farting a cloud. Kind of a step backwards there, buddy. (My little brother got a Wartortle, and when I saw this… oh, I mocked him horribly.)
Still, two out of three ain’t bad, and even though he looks a little retarded, Wartortle is still better looking than some of the other ones we’re going to see on our little romp. More on that later.
GRAAAAHH! MY MIND, SHE IS BLOWN.
I don’t even care that Venusaur’s name doesn’t make any sense (is that a palm tree with a flower on it?), he could eat your frikkin’ head. Charizard is a dragon! A DRAGON! He flies and shoots fire and looks utterly baddasssssss… but the real winner here, the one who made up for his step backwards last round by sprinting forwards (and beating the earth into submission so the rest of his trip was downhill so he could run faster) was Blastoise. Those are cannons. LOOK AT THE CANNONS. I didn’t even care that he had metal cannons coming out of his back, that was the coolest thing I’d ever seen (and I profusely apologized to the little bro once I saw that he’d traded his head-wings for BACK CANNONS; good trade, there).
Now begins the descent into suck. It’s slow at first, but you really start to feel the decline.
GENERATION II
The suck starts with Chikorita there. I have no idea what the balls that thing is even supposed to be. Some kind of… hairless hamster with a spiked collar and a leaf on it’s head? What the crap? Cyndaquil at least looked a little cool: he’s like an echidna with fire coming out of it’s back. Totodile makes the most sense here, but in the cartoon he was all ADHD and bouncy and I think he was mildly retarded. Not doing much to endear me, guys.

Sooo… it’s a dinosaur? Bayleaf still looks like a cop-out, and they’re going to have to pull a Blastoise in order to make it anything but a total disappointment when it comes to aesthetics. Quilava is less of a spiny thing now and more of a… what? A rodent? A fire-ferret? Cool name, but definitely in the awkward teenage years here. And Croconaw… sorry buddy. He seriously looks like somebody I went to school with. I think we all did: a little slow, not necessarily in the “special” class, but just kind of big and awkward. And… why is he wearing a caveman, over-the-shoulder tummy pattern? It’s just silly. 2.5 strikes for this set, fellas, saved only by Quilava’s name from getting a total strike out.

Aaaaand the disappointment. Meganium is like some kind of gay-pride alien brontosaurus here. I think they just started down the wrong path and couldn’t find their way back. Typhlosion, on the other hand, has the second- or third-coolest name of any Pokémon ever. I’m probably going to name my son that. “Typhlosion MacKenzie”. Heck yeah. Unfortunately, Feraligatr suffers from lack of spaces in the tiny game card’s memory and ends up with a name that was just one “o” away from being a decent monicker. He even looks pretty cool. It’s amazing what the lack of a vowel can do to you… sorry fellas. You tried, except for the Flowersaurusian there, and were stuck with the job of trying to out-do, or at least live up to, the perfection of Gen-1. Maybe next time…
But no. The roller coaster of suck has only just begun.
GENERATION III
These guys look… okay. I don’t mind what’s going on here. I at least recognize where they got the idea for Treecko: he’s a plant-based lizard thing. They’re even stereotypically green, so it’s a solid start; I don’t even mind that crap-eating grin he’s got on. Torchic has another great name, but… he’s a chicken. A fire chicken. What’s he going to do, other than grill himself? “Torchic used fricassee! It’s finger-lickin’ good!” No. And Mudkip… he’s got like spikey herpes on his face there. Why are you smiling, Mudkip? STD’s are no laughing matter.

What the heck, guys? Grovyle has wings now, and a pony-tail? There was the guy who could pull it off, and all those other guys who wanted to but couldn’t: guess which one you are, Grovyle? Who’s idea was this? And that grin is really starting to piss me off. Now, why doesn’t the fire-chicken have wings? Birds don’t have claws on their wing, so why should you, Combusken? Which is a terrible name, BTW. From “combust” and “chicken”. All you’re doing is making me hungry. You wouldn’t even make it to your final stage, you’d have been deep fried and covered in seven secret herbs and spices way before then. And you, Marshtomp… I don’t even know where to start with you. Your spike-herpes have seemed to calmed down a bit, but that stuff is never gonna go away. And the mohawk? One person can pull that off, Marshtomp, and you are no Mr. T.

… ugh. Just… just stop. Sceptile has a fern growing out of his butt, a couple goiters on his neck, and if he doesn’t wipe that look off his face I’m gonna do it for him. WITH A BASEBALL BAT. Blaziken, I know it isn’t your fault, but you have a horrible name: it’s like… they realized how stupid you look and tried to counter that by finding the most awesomest name evar, omg, like Dirk Awesomelazer or Phoenix McBadass, blatantly attempting and failing at the same time. And you, Swampert… I told you that the disease would spring up again. You look ridiculous, by the way, like you decided one mohawk wasn’t cool enough and figured two would be better, then decided THREE would be OFF THE CHAIN and put one on your butt. You were wrong. You were so, so wrong.
Fortunately, and right when I had given up hope, here comes an oasis, a bright spot in the dark, and reignited a glimmer of joy within my expansive and fuzzy breast.
GENERATION IV
It’s… it’s like I’m a kid again. They’re adorable. I have nothing negative to say about you, Turtwig: those leaves work so much better on you than they ever did on Treecko or Chikorita. Chimchar, you are so happy that your butt is on fire that I want to hug you and talk about how much I love that your butt is on fire. And Piplup, if you looked any sweeter, I’d probably have to start taking insulin or something cause I just developed the die-beetus. You three are like a triple play in the 7th inning of a baseball game that just had a three-hour middle where nothing happened: you pump some life into it and get the crowd excited again.

Grotle is this generation’s Wartortle: a silly teenage phase where we see potential, but don’t really know where it will lead. Monferno looks like a quarterback to me: easy confidence, not a hair out of place, and all the ladies love him. Plus, he realized that the fire on his butt, which probably made farting hilarious as a child but incredibly conspicuous as a teen, was a bad idea, so he moved it away by developing a tail. Wise move, sir. Prinplup, you lose points for both your lack of originality when it comes to your name, your dual mohawk (you might have been able to pull it off in Gen 6, but it’s too soon after Swampert, buddy), and for your pants-suit that goes up waaaay too high. He’s like Urkel a little bit… but the “Urkels” of the world also end up the “Bill Gates” of the world, so we’ll avoid judging you too harshly… for now.
HOME RUN! HOME RUN! GEN 4 GOT A HOME RUN IN THE BOTTOM OF THE 9TH!
Torterra, you’re carrying a tree and a mountain on your back. If you were real, I’d stick a La-Z-Boy up there, a mini TV and a fridge, and we’d see the world. Sure, it would probably take us a month to get to Indiana, but we would look awesome while doing it. Infernape, you’re, like, wearing armor, and you moved the fire as far away from your butt as you can, sticking with your whole “fire monkey” thing but reinventing yourself enough that people forget all about that one time you accidentally set your desk on fire your Junior year. Wise choice. And you, Empoleon… it’s like the guy who used to be in the AV department with tall pants and glasses went to college, started working out, got contacts, met a girl, then started a software company that reinvented the way people use their wrist-watches and made billions. He’s dressed up, he’s ready for business… guh. You wish you looked that good in a frilly shirt.
So good. SO GOOD. A taste of the glory days, guys. But you know what happens after a mountain?
That’s right. A valley.
GENERATION V
WHAT THE BALLS AM I EVEN LOOKING AT. This is the recently-released artwork for Gen. 5, Pokémon Black and White. They’ll probably sell a gazillion copies, cause Pokémon prints money, but you guys can do better than this. Their names haven’t been translated or properly word-played into English yet, so you’re looking at Tsutarja, Pokabu, and Mijumaru up there. I have no idea what those words mean either.
Is that another plant-lizard? Why? Did you not learn your lesson after Treecko? He’s even got that same look on his face! WHERE’S MY BAT?! And why is there another food-animal with fire powers? “Pokabu used barbecue! It’s super delicious!” But that last one… oh man. Oooooh, man. He isn’t even happy. He’s a sad, albino otter who hit the shell he was trying to open on his tummy SO HARD that it fused into his stomach-flesh. And he’s wearing a sweater vest. I’d be frowning too, but that doesn’t excuse his starter-status. He’s something you should run into a hundred times and learn to hate, like a Zubat or a Magikarp, not something that’s given to a kid who’s just starting out on his journey into the world to help him beat that world into submission.
We don’t even know what their next forms look like, they’re that new. I’ll tell you, though: my hopes are not high. I’m gonna go hang out with my Torterra now, relax in my La-Z-Boy, and slowly amble into the sunset to look for my bat.